Kabir Singh controversy and glorification of misogyny

Violent and misogynist? Does the character, Kabir Singh played by Shahid Kapoor, fit in this category? The answer is a reverberate and massive YES! I am not against showing misogyny in movies. I understand that not all movies are made for educational purposes, nor every movie needs to be morally correct. The only issue I have with this movie is, that it ended up normalising, in fact “glorifying” toxic relationship. How is it okay to justify violence against women in the name of ‘love’?

Okay, not only the hero but I also have issues with the heroine’s character. The woman is too demure, sometimes almost mute. All she does is ‘babying’ him in the movie. She lacks a backbone and is so gullible that it becomes irritating to watch her after a point, though the actress has done a good job.

JUSTIFICATION OF TOXIC MASCULINITY

Though the film is good in direction, screenplay and acting, it is the characterisation which is extremely problematic. Why is it so difficult for some people to understand that love should be liberating and not scary or overwhelming.

MISOGYNIST – Why I feel this movie is wrong on so many levels

There is a blatant glorification of misogyny and this movie tries to justify a sexist and toxic relationship. There should be mutual respect in a relationship. You do not own your partner. Your partner is your companion, not your property to slap her/him or decide whom she can talk to or be with friends with.

When the girl’s father refuses to accept him, he slaps her and leaves her crying and goes off giving an ultimatum. What would you do in such a case? Break his bones and break off with him, right? But here, she clings to him even more and begs him to not leave her! I know, totally bizarre!

I haven’t even come to the body-shaming part. He instructs her to be friends with only fat girls! Can somebody tell the director that Fat shaming is not cool? This character is so flawed and angry with the whole world that he doesn’t even behave properly with his family. And did I mention that he tries to sexually assault a girl in the opening scene itself?

KABIR SINGH BOX OFFICE COLLECTION

The Shahid Kapoor starrer has already crossed 200 Crore mark in just two weeks! It has become one of the highest-grossing films of 2019. The controversy around the film definitely helped it in raking huge numbers. As they say, negative publicity is also good publicity!

KABIR SINGH FILM CONTROVERSY

In an interview with Anupam Chopra, the director of this movie Sandeep Reddy said “When you are deeply in love and are connected to a woman, if you don’t have the liberty of slapping each other, then I don’t see anything there”. He further stated that the people who are complaining now have never experienced real love! Since then, the director has been trolled and criticised on social media.

Badminton player Jwala Gutta wrote, “Movie was a movie…but justifying physical abuse?? If u love someone u have the right to slap? Gosh…this guy needs to be shown all the love without physical hurt!! Pathetic!!”

Kubbra Sait took to twitter and instagram to share two videos, which take a dig on Sandeep Reddy Vanga’s statement. In one video, Kubbra is seen slapping herself. She wrote, “If you can’t love yourself, you haven’t really loved yourself.”

Sona Mohapatra in her tweet said, “Does the actor have no responsibility for choosing to play a part in a narrative that can set us back as a society? Is that all we have become? Creatures of ambition?” When some twitter user pointed out that she had sung an item song ‘Bedardi Raja’, Sona wrote, “U are the nth moron trying to make such a false equivalence. A woman singing lustily & celebrating her own sexuality isn’t likely to cause violence & isn’t the same thing as a man grabbing a woman without her consent, kissing her apart from several other such toxic masculine acts.”

The copyright of this poster belongs to the graphic artist/film maker/distributor.

Have you watched this movie? Drop in your comments. Would love to hear your views. Check this article from Hindustan Times in case you are interested in reading other reactions for his controversial statement. Click here .

Published by

Sneha

Sneha is an award-winning blogger and has also been featured in Deccan Chronicle newspaper. She left her job at IBM India to venture into blogging in 2018. This blog is India's Feminist and Personal Development blog for women and focuses on self-improvement and self-acceptance.

27 thoughts on “Kabir Singh controversy and glorification of misogyny”

  1. It’s already glorified enough that the misogynist remarks have seen an upsurge in the public. It has certainly made everyone receptive towards the toxic relationships. Never seen someone slap to show off the love.
    Well the movie did something and did it well. Showed us the path to a changing India. Now it’s very responsive and vibrant towards such sensitive issues.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Absolutely 🙂 The only issue I have with the movie is the over glorification. There is nothing wrong in showing flawed and toxic characters but why defend them?

      Liked by 1 person

  2. Do you see more movies like this being made in the future?
    I guess they are being made as a weapon to awaken those stigmas/taboos in our country.
    Well such movies have indeed given a hype to these social issues prevalent. They need some glorification for the purification.
    Defending them is certainly not a good choice.

    Liked by 1 person

  3. Hey, I completely agree with you. I didn’t watch the movie because I couldn’t have watched a film like that. Now that I read your post, it’s all very clear. I can’t believe slapping a woman can be ‘romantic’. And people are still defending this glorification! This is sick! Anyway, your post is very well-framed🙂

    Like

  4. I don’t know I am right or wrong but I want to share my views on Movie Kabir Singh. I have watched the movie and I found it okay(with some bad behavior by the actor). There are many who are criticizing the movie because they found that this movie is against the feminism. I can agree with them for some scene in the movie.
    But, I want to show the other side of the coin. They were in love with each other and no one forced them to be. They were slapping each other in the movie. so, it’s not okay to blame the actor for his aggression. And, the girl was comfortable with the boy in the movie that’s why she fought to her family and wanted to spend the rest of her life with him. We can’t force anyone to think the same, what we think.
    If someone is going through a bad phase or lost something which is most important for him/her. They will not react in the way we wanted them to react. It’s human nature. There are many boys/girls who started drinking after a breakup. And some started visiting brothels. I don’t want to comment on them because I don’t know how hard is it for them to accept that someone left him/her.
    At last, I have watched the movie and I have taken the positive things. Like, In the era of money, face, and sex. He loved, her from all his heart and she did the same.
    This might surprise you, that there are 80% of people having extramarital affairs (I am saying this because I know).
    Sorry, If my opinion hurts anyone out here.

    Like

      1. I haven’t seen such type of romance and love in my life where lovers slap each other. This is just a movie and people are enjoying. They are making this type of movies because of us.
        Thank you very much.

        Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s